It often falls upon the family matriarch to host any large gathering, and Thanksgiving is no exception. At this point in your life, you’ve maybe hosted dozens of family holidays and you’re maybe feeling a bit … tired.

It’s not that you’re not looking forward to having everyone together, under one roof and getting in some much-needed quality time. It’s just that Thanksgiving is such a labor-intensive holiday — getting the house ready to host a crowd, the planning, the shopping and ugh, the cooking. It is endless! And then, you’re stuck trying to store more leftovers than you know what to do with. 

If you’re feeling like it’s time to try something new and different, you’re not alone. Here are some of our favorite shortcuts for making the hosting gig easier, and alternative approaches that may help you look forward to the holiday. 

Caitlin Manner with her "dessert turkey": a chocolate-dipped strawberry with mini-marshmallows and pretzel sticks.
The author with her “dessert turkey”: a chocolate-dipped strawberry with mini-marshmallows and pretzel sticks. This was one of the successful ones. (Photo courtesy Caitlin Manner)

Does It Have to be Turkey?

A giant roasted turkey is almost always the centerpiece of a traditional Thanksgiving feast … but it doesn’t have to be. Even the best-prepared turkey can be dry and relatively flavorless. It’s a perfect vehicle for smothering in gravy and stuffing, but it’s not necessarily the delectable treat you might be craving. 

To change things up a bit, why not make something else that will still feel special and decadent? For years, my family would groan because my uncle always insisted on serving prime rib for Thanksgiving dinner. (“That’s not what you’re supposed to eat!? It’s called Turkey Day for a reason!?”) But in retrospect, the man was onto something. The meal was actually a celebration of eating something we couldn’t afford to have all that often. 

The point is, don’t be afraid to change the menu, at least a little bit. You could go for something like Duck a L’Orange, for example, if you don’t want to stray too far from the traditional path. Some other ideas are Beef Wellington, Leg of Lamb or a vegetarian Mince Pie. (You can find 25 mouth-watering alternative Thanksgiving suggestions on Food & Wine, and be sure to peruse Once Upon a Chef for Jenn Segal’s takes on much-loved Thanksgiving classics as well!)

Order In

If you want to enjoy the family time and skip slaving away in the kitchen, why not order takeout? No one said you have to shed your own blood, sweat and tears for Thanksgiving dinner to be special! Dozens of local eateries offer catered meals for the holiday, whether you want just the turkey or the whole shebang. Just be sure to place your order early, as many sell out pretty quickly. 

rustic Thanksgiving place setting
One way to revamp your Thanksgiving celebration is to embrace your inner Martha Stewart and go all in. (Source: Darya Fedorova, via Canva.com)

Change Up the Vibes

Another way to add a little excitement to any holiday that’s gotten a bit stale is to diverge from your traditions entirely. Break up the tired old routine and you’ll find yourself anticipating the holiday in a whole new way. Here are some ideas for revamping your celebrations:

  • Embrace your inner Martha Stewart and go all in. That’s right: Make a signature cocktail for everyone to enjoy. Create place cards with decoupage fall leaves and handwritten calligraphy. Offer a giant charcuterie board. Make your pie crusts from scratch with elaborate designs baked in. You want your guests to walk in and go, “Whoa, you really upped your game!” This approach might offer two kinds of satisfaction: If you’re crafty, you can now focus on the joy of creating things rather than the dread of the whole production; your efforts will also get rewarded with appreciative feedback that will make you feel amazing. (That, or you can all share a good laugh over any failures. I personally derive endless joy from people good-naturedly teasing me for the very “special-looking” turkeys I made one year for dessert. At least it was memorable!)
  • Have a themed Thanksgiving. For example, if you have upcoming travel plans, you could create a feast centered around the local cuisine of your destination. Or you could decide to replicate the original Thanksgiving menu with a focus on seafood and local produce. One year, I declared the theme was “bacon” — and boy, that did not disappoint.
  • Make it a potluck meal, and ask everyone to make/bring one dish they’ve never had before but always wanted to try.
  • Make everything mini. Think cornish game hens, baby potatoes, baby carrots — or even Petite Beef Wellington. Everything will be adorable, and maybe everyone won’t overeat. 
  • Plan new activities. Maybe it’s not the meal you’re dreading, but that period of time when everyone else is just sitting around watching you cook. You could plan a morning hike, run a Turkey Trot 5K or go to the park for a family game of touch football. In case the weather doesn’t cooperate for outdoor activities, have indoor alternatives planned. One of our favorite family games is to have people pick a “hot-take” (a controversial opinion on something relatively benign) to adamantly defend in debate. For example: “A hot dog is a sandwich,” or “Leggings aren’t pants.” You’d be surprised at some of the points that come up, and it’s endlessly entertaining.

Top image: Bia Braz from baseimage, via Canva.com


More Articles You May Like: